Jerusalem and Athens: The Congruity of Talmudic and Classical Philosophy (Supplements to the Journal for the Study of Judaism, Volume 52)

By Jacob Neusner

The Talmud - the Mishnah, a philosophical legislation code, and the Gemara, a dialectical statement upon the Mishnah - works by means of translating imperative modes of Western philosophy and technology into the research of the principles of rationality governing the principles of humble, daily truth. technological know-how, particularly the strategy of hierarchical class attribute of average historical past, offers the strategy of creating connections and drawing conclusions to the Mishnah, the law-code that types the foundation-document of the Talmud, as Neusner confirmed in his "Judaism as Philosophy. the tactic and Message of the Mishnah," right here he proceeds to teach how philosophy, in particular dialectical research, defines the common sense of the Gemara and courses the writers of the Gemara's compositions and the compilers of its composites of their research and amplification of a few of the topical displays, or tractates, of the Mishnah.

Show description

Preview of Jerusalem and Athens: The Congruity of Talmudic and Classical Philosophy (Supplements to the Journal for the Study of Judaism, Volume 52) PDF

Best Judaism books

The Jewish Holidays: A Guide and Commentary

The coeditor of the drastically renowned Jewish Catalog "help[s] readers comprehend extra totally the which means of our vacation trips and thereby to monitor those gala's . . . with a better devotion and pleasure. "--Rabbi Alexander M. Schindler

About the author
MICHAEL STRASSFELD is the rabbi of the Society for the development of Judaism, a synagogue. He lives in ny together with his spouse, Rabbi
Joy Levitt, and their 5 children.

Originally released in 1985.
E-published in 2011.

A History of the Jews

A countrywide bestseller, this superb 4000 12 months survey covers not just Jewish background yet he effect of Jewish genius and mind's eye at the global. by way of the writer of contemporary instances: the realm From the Twenties to the Eighties.

How to Be a Mentsh (and Not a Shmuck)

Certain to resonate with Jewish and Gentile readers alike, the way to Be a Mentsh (and now not a Shmuck) is a smart and witty self-help handbook for pursuing happiness whereas nonetheless appearing with integrity, honor, and compassion. Michael Wex, manhattan instances bestselling writer of Born to Kvetch and simply Say Nu, attracts on assets that diversity from the Talmud and Yiddish proverbs to modern track and flicks during this insightful consultant that explores not just human nature and psychology but our tasks to ourselves and each other.

Antisemitism: A Very Short Introduction (Very Short Introductions)

Antisemitism, as hatred of Jews and Judaism, has been a crucial challenge of Western civilization for millennia, and its background keeps to ask debate. This Very brief creation untangles the historical past of the phenomenon, from old non secular clash to 'new' antisemitism within the twenty first century. Steven Beller unearths how Antisemitism grew as a political and ideological stream within the nineteenth century, the way it reached its darkish apogee within the worst genocide in glossy historical past - the Holocaust - and the way Antisemitism nonetheless persists world wide this present day.

Extra resources for Jerusalem and Athens: The Congruity of Talmudic and Classical Philosophy (Supplements to the Journal for the Study of Judaism, Volume 52)

Show sample text content

I will be able to open any web page of the Mishnah for examples of accurately these differences and recognitions. what's at stake in dialectic is said through Allan as follows: Dialectic will locate a few universal starting place for these unproved assumptions upon which all clinical reasoning relies, and, typically, will make our fragmentary adventure a part of one coherent method, now not by means of assembling the fragments and piecing them jointly, yet by means of an intuitive snatch of a critical useful fact . . . from which all partial fact will be deduced with no possibility of blunders. 29 within the Mishnah and Gemara we discover ourselves at domestic with a philosophy that goals at presenting coherence to wisdom and adventure. allow us to now flip to work out accurately how the Gemara particularly accomplishes that goal of discovering the norm via systematic rivalry. For, as with Classical philosophy, the authors of the Gemara's dialectical composites took as their premise that out of rigorous and unyielding clash referring to fact, fact emerges. 27 28 29 Owens, p. 305, bringing up Aristotle, as indicated in his notes. Ibid. Allan, op. cit. , p. a hundred forty five. seventy four bankruptcy 3 II. WHY DIALECTICS was once the selected MEDIUM OF proposal AND EXPRESSION FOR THE MISHNAH'S HEIRS AND CONTINUATORS the following we come to the severe query, how do we account for the Talmud's inn to dialectical argument, which had no precedent whatever in previous Israelite writing of any variety? a lot of the Talmud accomplishes its targets with no inn to contentious argument, not to mention to the asking and answering of questions, so the paintings of Mishnah-commentary may have been complete with no dialectics. however the Talmud's unmarried indi~ative trait, although now not a paramount or ubiquitous one, is its dialectics, and now we have each cause to wish to grasp why. 30 simply because they inherited a corpus of clash, a background of contending statements of norms and legislation, the heirs of the Mishnah, featuring to proceed the paintings of the Mishnah, present in dialectics the proper medium of expression and suggestion for reaching their activity of confronting rivalry and resolving disharmony. If the Torah \ of the Lord used to be to be perfected, because the Psalmist held, then it used to be via dialectics that our sages may either reveal the perfection of the Mishnah, the transcription of the oral Torah of Sinai, and in addition eliminate the imperfections of the legislation that the Torah passed directly to Israel. to appreciate what pointed out dialectical inquiry because the medium of selection for attaining the objectives of the framers of the Gemara's composites and authors of its compositions, we need to evaluation the Gemara's personal projects. prepared round the Mishnah within the type of a observation to that rfile, the Gemara that including the Mishnah contains the Tahnud of Babylonia, a. ok. a. , the Bavli, accords privileged status to the Mishnah. the shape of the Gemara, its ideas of association and its systematic application, all accord precedence to the Mishnah. yet that's deceptive. For, bearing secondary advancements and likewise giant topical appendices, in addition to freestanding composites of Scripture-commentary, the Gemara of the.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.06 of 5 – based on 6 votes