A Nation on Trial: The Goldhagen Thesis and Historical Truth

By Norman G. Finkelstein

No contemporary paintings of historical past has generated as a lot curiosity as Daniel Jonah Goldhagen's Hitler's prepared Executioners. Purporting to unravel the secret of the Nazi holocaust, Goldhagen continues that standard Germans have been pushed by means of fanatical anti-Semitism to homicide the Jews. a right away nationwide best-seller, the ebook went directly to create a world sensation.

Now, in A state on Trial, top critics problem Goldhagen's findings and express that his paintings isn't really scholarship in any respect. With compelling cumulative impact, Norman G. Finkelstein meticulously files Goldhagen's distortions of secondary literature and the interior contradictions of his argument. In a complementary essay, Ruth Bettina Birn juxtaposes Goldhagen's textual content opposed to the German information he consulted. the most important foreign authority on those documents, Birn conclusively demonstrates that Goldhagen systematically misrepresented their contents.

The definitive assertion at the Goldhagen phenomenon, this quantity is additionally a cautionary story at the corruption of scholarship by way of ideological zealotry.

Show description

Preview of A Nation on Trial: The Goldhagen Thesis and Historical Truth PDF

Best Judaism books

The Jewish Holidays: A Guide and Commentary

The coeditor of the greatly well known Jewish Catalog "help[s] readers comprehend extra absolutely the which means of our vacation trips and thereby to monitor those gala's . . . with a better devotion and pleasure. "--Rabbi Alexander M. Schindler

About the author
MICHAEL STRASSFELD is the rabbi of the Society for the development of Judaism, a synagogue. He lives in long island together with his spouse, Rabbi
Joy Levitt, and their 5 children.

Originally released in 1985.
E-published in 2011.

A History of the Jews

A countrywide bestseller, this very good 4000 yr survey covers not just Jewish background yet he influence of Jewish genius and mind's eye at the international. by way of the writer of contemporary instances: the area From the Twenties to the Eighties.

How to Be a Mentsh (and Not a Shmuck)

Certain to resonate with Jewish and Gentile readers alike, the right way to Be a Mentsh (and now not a Shmuck) is a smart and witty self-help guide for pursuing happiness whereas nonetheless performing with integrity, honor, and compassion. Michael Wex, big apple occasions bestselling writer of Born to Kvetch and simply Say Nu, attracts on assets that diversity from the Talmud and Yiddish proverbs to modern tune and films during this insightful advisor that explores not just human nature and psychology but our tasks to ourselves and each other.

Antisemitism: A Very Short Introduction (Very Short Introductions)

Antisemitism, as hatred of Jews and Judaism, has been a imperative challenge of Western civilization for millennia, and its heritage keeps to ask debate. This Very brief advent untangles the historical past of the phenomenon, from historical non secular clash to 'new' antisemitism within the twenty first century. Steven Beller finds how Antisemitism grew as a political and ideological flow within the nineteenth century, the way it reached its darkish apogee within the worst genocide in smooth background - the Holocaust - and the way Antisemitism nonetheless persists world wide this present day.

Additional resources for A Nation on Trial: The Goldhagen Thesis and Historical Truth

Show sample text content

Traditional Germans and the Holocaust. by way of Daniel Jonah Goldhagen. London: Little Brown and corporate, 1996. Pp. x+622. £20. I questions about the explanations of the perpetrators and, through implication, the reasons of the Holocaust, have lengthy been within the vanguard of educational or non-academic discussions of the Nazi interval – from the time of up to date observers to the current day. quite a lot of attainable responses to those questions has been recommend, drawing on suggestions from various disciplines, akin to heritage, psychology, sociology or theology. Daniel Goldhagen's e-book at the motivation of the perpetrators of the Holocaust claims to be a 'radical revision of what has in the past been written' (p. 9). This declare is made at the book-jacket and through the writer himself. His thesis might be summarized as follows: Germany used to be permeated by means of a very radical and harsh model of anti-Semitism whose target used to be the removing of Jews. the writer defines this as 'eliminationist anti-Semitism'. This viral pressure of anti-Semitism, he states, 'resided eventually within the center of German political tradition, in German society itself' (p. 428). Medieval anti-Semitism, established because it was once at the teachings of the Christian faith, used to be so 'integral to German tradition' (p. fifty five) that with the emergence of the modem period it didn't disappear yet fairly took on new different types of expression, specifically, racial elements. through the tip of the 19th century 'eliminationist antiSemitism' ruled the German political scene. within the Weimar Republic, it grew extra virulent even earlier than Hitler got here to strength. The Nazi desktop simply grew to become this ideology right into a fact. The process its actualization used to be now not deterred via whatever retailer naked necessity: 'the street to Auschwitz used to be now not twisted' (p. 425). while the 'genocidal application' was once applied besides the German assault at the Soviet Union, it was once supported by means of the final German inhabitants, via the 'ordinary Germans' – the major word of the publication – who turned 'willing executioners. they'd little need ∗ The perspectives expressed listed here are these of the writer and never these of the dept of justice, Canada. fifty four of exact orders, coercion or strain simply because their 'cognitive version' confirmed them that Jews have been eventually healthy in simple terms to undergo and to die' (p. 316). Daniel Goldhagen's e-book has develop into a global occasion. He has been interviewed and quoted, seemed on television and travelled greatly to debate his paintings. [196] stories, either enthusiastic and significant, have poured from the presses in lots of international locations. it really is not easy to consider a wide educational booklet that has had this type of reception or even tougher to provide an explanation for why. The e-book itself is made of 3 elements: an summary of German historical past and the importance of anti-Semitism therein, 3 case reports, and approximately pages of conclusions. the 1st, basic part has been the topic of lots of the recognition of reviewers. This evaluation will, hence, be aware of the case stories, the resources which Mr. Goldhagen has used and the technique on which the publication rests.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.91 of 5 – based on 3 votes